12 So-Called Dumbest Dog Breeds (Independent, Not Dim)
Every list of the dumbest dog breeds is really a list of the most independent ones. We break down the 12 breeds that top these rankings, from the Afghan Hound to the Chihuahua, explain the real behavior behind each reputation, and share exactly.
Petful is reader supported. As an affiliate of platforms like Amazon and Chewy, we may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. There is no extra cost to you.
Every list of the dumbest dog breeds is really a list of the most independent ones. The breeds that land at the bottom of canine obedience rankings are not slow-witted. They are stubborn, self-directed, and often smart enough to decide your command is not worth their time. A Basenji that ignores "come" is not confused about what you want. It has simply weighed its options and picked the more interesting one.
This distinction matters because the popular "dumb dog" label comes almost entirely from one measurement: how quickly a breed learns and obeys human commands. That is a narrow slice of intelligence, and it says nothing about problem-solving, scent work, emotional attunement, or the quiet cleverness of a dog that figures out how to open your refrigerator. Below, we walk through the 12 breeds most often called the dumbest dog breeds, explain the real behavior behind each reputation, and show you how to train the independent thinkers that everyone else gave up on.
- 1"Dumbest" almost always means "least obedient," not "least intelligent."
- 2Most of these breeds were bred for independent jobs (sighthounds chase, scent hounds track) that reward ignoring the handler.
- 3With the right motivation and short, high-value sessions, nearly every breed on this list can learn the same commands as a Border Collie.
Sign up for expert-backed reviews and safety alerts all in one place.
What "Dumbest Dog Breed" Actually Measures
The rankings behind almost every dumbest-dog-breeds list trace back to canine psychologist Stanley Coren and his 1994 book, *The Intelligence of Dogs*. Coren surveyed hundreds of professional dog-obedience judges and sorted 138 breeds by how many repetitions they needed to learn a new command and how reliably they obeyed it on the first try. The breeds at the bottom were not the ones that failed puzzles. They were the ones that took 80 to 100 repetitions to learn something a Poodle picked up in fewer than five.
Coren himself split intelligence into three parts, and the popular lists only capture one of them.
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
- Instinctive intelligence is the job a breed was built to do without being taught: a Border Collie herding, a Bloodhound trailing a scent, a Basenji hunting silently. Every dog on this list scores high here.
- Adaptive intelligence is how well a dog solves problems on its own, learns from its environment, and figures out situations you never trained for. This is where the "dumb" breeds quietly shine.
- Working and obedience intelligence is the narrow, trainability-focused score that produces the rankings. It measures how fast a dog does what a human asks, which is exactly the trait an independent breed was designed to override.
So when a breed is called one of the dumbest dog breeds, the honest translation is: it does not drop what it is doing to obey you on command number one. For a sighthound built to make split-second chase decisions a quarter-mile from its handler, that is not a bug. It is the whole point.
- Nearly every "dumbest dog breeds" article online, including the AI summaries at the top of Google, draws from the same Coren obedience rankings. It is a single 30-year-old survey of obedience judges, not a measure of raw canine IQ. Treat the ranking as a trainability guide, not a verdict on how clever your dog is.
The 12 So-Called Dumbest Dog Breeds
We ranked these roughly from most independent to least, following the breeds that consistently appear at the bottom of Coren's obedience list and across the current top-ranking articles. For each one, you will find why it earned the reputation and the single training key that unlocks it.
1. Afghan Hound
The Afghan Hound sits at the very bottom of Coren's obedience ranking, and it wears the crown of "dumbest" almost every time the topic comes up. The reality is a 2,000-year-old sighthound bred to chase gazelle and leopard across Afghan mountains, making life-or-death decisions on its own, far from any human voice. Independence was the job description.
That heritage produces a dog that hears your command perfectly and then decides, with visible dignity, that it has better things to do. Afghans are aloof, cat-like, and famously slow to obey, which reads as stupidity to anyone expecting instant recall. But their problem-solving and their memory for the things they care about are sharp. Train an Afghan with patience, novelty, and a chase-based reward like a flirt pole, and the "dumbest" dog in America starts looking a lot smarter.
2. Basenji
The Basenji, the "barkless dog" of Central Africa, is one of the oldest breeds on Earth and one of the most cat-like. It grooms itself fastidiously, dislikes rain, and treats human commands as gentle suggestions. Bred to hunt independently and even to drive game into nets, the Basenji thinks for itself by design.
Daily dental chew that cleans teeth, freshens breath, and is accepted by the Veterinary Oral Health Council. Sized for dogs 25 to 50 lbs.
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
Its low obedience score is a direct result of that self-reliance, not any lack of wits. Basenjis are notorious escape artists and problem-solvers, the kind of dog that studies a latch until it opens. Owners who succeed keep training sessions short, unpredictable, and genuinely rewarding, because a bored Basenji will simply invent its own more interesting agenda.
3. Bulldog
The Bulldog earns its spot less through stubbornness and more through a deep, unhurried commitment to comfort. Affectionate and people-loving, the Bulldog learns at its own deliberate pace and often decides that a nap outranks a training drill. That mellow refusal to hustle gets logged as low trainability.
There is a health note worth knowing here too. As a brachycephalic (flat-faced) breed, the Bulldog can develop Brachycephalic Obstructive Airway Syndrome, which limits its heat tolerance and stamina. According to the American College of Veterinary Surgeons, affected dogs struggle to breathe efficiently, so a Bulldog that quits a session early may be managing its airway, not ignoring you. Keep training cool, short, and low-exertion, and this loyal breed learns just fine.
- Brachycephalic breeds like the Bulldog and Pekingese overheat quickly and tire fast. The American College of Veterinary Surgeons notes that Brachycephalic Obstructive Airway Syndrome makes efficient breathing hard, so what looks like laziness or defiance during training can be genuine physical strain. Train in short bursts in a cool space and never push a panting flat-faced dog.
4. Chow Chow
The Chow Chow is one of the most cat-like dogs alive: dignified, aloof, deeply loyal to one or two people, and utterly uninterested in performing tricks for approval. Training a Chow feels less like teaching and more like negotiating with a stubborn toddler who happens to have a lion's mane.
This is an ancient Chinese breed built for guarding and hunting, roles that reward judgment over obedience. Chows bond hard but obey selectively, and they will not work for empty praise. Early, consistent socialization matters enormously with this breed, and rewards need to be worth its while. The Chow is not dim. It is discerning.
5. Borzoi
The Borzoi, or Russian wolfhound, is one of the fastest dogs on the planet and one of the quietest thinkers. Bred by Russian nobility to sight and chase wolves across vast estates, the Borzoi makes independent, high-speed decisions with zero input from a handler. Sitting on command was never part of the resume.
That gives the Borzoi a low obedience score and a reputation for being one of the dumbest dog breeds, when in truth it is elegant, sensitive, and highly attuned to movement. Borzois respond poorly to repetition and harsh correction and much better to gentle, motivation-based training that respects their dignity. A securely fenced yard matters more than a perfect recall, because the chase instinct will always win a fair fight.
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
6. Bloodhound
The Bloodhound is proof that "dumb" is the wrong word entirely. Its nose is so powerful that law enforcement uses Bloodhound trailing evidence in court, and a single dog can follow a days-old scent for miles. The catch: once that nose locks onto a trail, the rest of the world, including your voice, effectively switches off.
That single-minded scent drive tanks its obedience score. A Bloodhound is not ignoring you out of spite; it is neurologically hijacked by the most interesting smell in the county. Recall is genuinely hard with this breed, which is why leashed walks and secure fencing are non-negotiable. Channel that focus into scent games and nose work, and you will see just how brilliant this "dumb" dog really is.
7. Pekingese
Bred for centuries to sit in the sleeves of Chinese emperors, the Pekingese carries itself like royalty and treats obedience training as beneath its station. Brave, opinionated, and deeply loyal to its chosen person, the Peke will often simply decline a command it finds tedious.
Like the Bulldog, the Pekingese is brachycephalic, so it shares the same heat and breathing limits, and short sessions are a health matter as much as a training one. This is a smart little dog with an oversized sense of self. It responds to respect, patience, and rewards it deems acceptable, and it does not respond at all to being ordered around.
8. Basset Hound
The Basset Hound tops several current dumbest-dog-breeds lists, and it is another case of a scent hound being punished for doing its job too well. Those famous long ears and loose skin help sweep scent toward one of the most sensitive noses in the dog world, second only to the Bloodhound. When a Basset catches a trail, obedience evaporates.
Add a stubborn streak and a low-slung, unhurried build, and you get a dog that is slow to respond and easily distracted. But Bassets are gentle, patient, and genuinely food-motivated, which is the training loophole. Keep them on leash, use their nose as the reward with scent-based games, and pay in treats, and the "dumbest" hound cooperates more than its reputation suggests.
9. Beagle
The Beagle is the friendly, food-obsessed scent hound that everyone loves and few can train off-leash. Beagles are genuinely intelligent, curious, and driven, which is precisely why they appear on dumbest-dog-breeds lists: that curiosity and nose almost always outrank your recall. A Beagle mid-scent is running its own program.
The KONG Classic is the gold-standard durable chew + treat-stuffer for high-drive working breeds like the Belgian Malinois. The large size fits the breed's bite, and the natural red rubber survives the chew habits that destroy lesser toys.
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
This is a pack hound bred to hunt in groups and follow rabbits for hours, so independence and persistence are features. The good news is the Beagle's bottomless appetite makes it one of the more trainable breeds on this list, as long as your treats are more exciting than the smell it just found. Consistency, a secure yard, and high-value food rewards do the trick.
10. Mastiff
The Mastiff is calm, headstrong, and deeply devoted, an ancient guardian breed that thinks before it acts. That deliberation reads as slowness on an obedience test. A Mastiff will not rush to sit the instant you ask; it processes the request, considers it, and complies on its own dignified timeline.
Do not mistake that pace for a lack of intelligence. Mastiffs are perceptive, protective, and highly aware of their people and surroundings, which is exactly what a guardian needs. Because of their enormous size, early training and socialization are essential and far easier while the dog is small. Firm, kind, consistent guidance produces a gentle giant that is a joy to live with.
11. Shih Tzu
The Shih Tzu was bred for one job: to be a beloved companion in Chinese and Tibetan palaces. Charm was the assignment, not obedience, and it shows. Shih Tzus can be delightfully stubborn about training, especially house-training, which lands them on plenty of dumbest-dog-breeds lists.
But a dog bred purely to read and please its humans is socially sharp in ways an obedience test never measures. Shih Tzus are affectionate, perceptive, and quick to learn what earns them attention. Positive reinforcement, patience with house-training, and short fun sessions bring out a companion that is exactly as clever as it needs to be.
12. Chihuahua
The Chihuahua rounds out the list not because it lacks brains, but because it has a giant personality in a tiny body and a strong sense of its own agenda. Chihuahuas can be willful, easily distracted, and quick to decide that a command is optional, which reads as low trainability.
In truth the Chihuahua is alert, quick-learning, and fiercely bonded to its person. The common problem is that owners under-train small dogs and let cute behavior slide, which creates the stubborn reputation. Treat a Chihuahua like a real dog with real, consistent, reward-based training, and you get a sharp, confident little companion.
Multiple ridges and valleys slow eating, reduce gas and bloating, and turn mealtime into a fun puzzle. Non-skid base, dishwasher safe, 4-cup capacity.
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
The Smartest and "Dumbest" Breeds, Side by Side
The gap between the top and bottom of Coren's obedience ranking is stark on paper, but it measures repetitions to learn, not raw cleverness. Here is how the extremes compare on the one metric these lists actually track.
| Breed | Obedience Rank Tier | What It Really Means |
|---|---|---|
| Border Collie | Top tier (fastest) | Learns new commands in under 5 repetitions; the benchmark for "smart" |
| Poodle | Top tier | Near-instant command learning; eager to please |
| Afghan Hound | Bottom tier | Needs 80-100+ repetitions; independent by design, not dim |
| Basset Hound | Bottom tier | Nose overrides commands; highly food-motivated in training |
| Bulldog | Bottom tier | Learns at its own pace; comfort and airway limits play a role |
Notice that every "bottom tier" breed has a clear, non-intelligence reason for its score: a powerful nose, a chase instinct, a flat face, or a mind of its own. None of them are actually stupid. If you want the other end of the spectrum, our companion guide to the smartest dog breeds breaks down the fast-learning, eager-to-please breeds that top the same ranking, and why "smart" and "easy to live with" are not always the same thing.
Independence, it turns out, is baked into a breed's history rather than its coat or its looks. The same is true of the appearance quirks people obsess over. If you enjoy the way heritage shapes a breed, our deep dive on Rhodesian Ridgeback colors shows how a working background leaves its mark on everything from temperament to markings.
How to Train an Independent ("Dumb") Dog
The breeds on this list are not untrainable. They are unmotivated by the things that motivate a Border Collie, so the standard playbook needs a few adjustments.
- Make the reward outrank the distraction. For a scent hound, your treat has to beat the smell on the ground. Use small, high-value food (real meat, cheese) and save the best rewards for recall.
- Keep sessions short and unpredictable. Independent breeds bore fast. Three to five minutes, a few times a day, beats one long slog. Change up the order and location so the dog stays engaged.
- Lean into the instinct, don't fight it. Give a Borzoi a flirt pole, a Bloodhound a scent trail, a Basenji a puzzle. Channeling the drive is far more effective than suppressing it.
- Respect the dignified breeds. Chows, Afghans, and Mastiffs shut down under harsh correction. Reward-based methods and genuine respect get cooperation; ordering them around gets a blank stare.
- Secure your space. For sighthounds and scent hounds, a fenced yard and a leash are not optional. No amount of training reliably beats a hardwired chase or trail instinct in the moment.
- Start young where you can. Early socialization and training are dramatically easier, especially for large, headstrong breeds like the Mastiff and Chow Chow.
- Find what your dog genuinely wants, food, a chase, a sniff, a game, and make that the payoff for doing what you ask. An "independent" dog is just a dog that has not yet been offered a good enough deal.
The Bottom Line on the Dumbest Dog Breeds
The dumbest dog breeds are almost never the least intelligent ones. They are the sighthounds, scent hounds, guardians, and lapdogs that were bred to think for themselves, follow their noses, or simply charm their way through life, none of which shows up on an obedience test. An Afghan Hound choosing not to come when called is not confused. A Bloodhound lost in a scent is not slow. A Chow Chow negotiating your request is not dim.
If you love a breed on this list, train to its instincts, reward what it actually values, and drop the "dumb" label for good. You do not have a stupid dog. You have an independent one, and independence, once you learn to work with it, is one of the most rewarding traits a dog can have.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an Independent Breed Right for You?
An independent dog rewards a specific kind of owner and quietly frustrates everyone else. Before you fall for an Afghan Hound or a Basenji, be honest about your patience, your schedule, and what you actually want from a dog. These breeds suit people who treat training as a long game and do not need instant, showy obedience to feel proud.
- First-time owner: a food-driven Beagle or Chihuahua forgives beginner mistakes; a Chow Chow or Borzoi does not. Start with the easier end of this list.
- Off-leash dreams: scent hounds and sighthounds are the wrong pick, because their instincts will out-vote your recall in open space every time.
- Time and space: short daily sessions and a securely fenced yard are the real price of entry.
Related on Petful
- The 20 Smartest Dog Breeds, Ranked by Intelligence
- Hound Dog Breeds: The Complete List With Photos
- The 7 Types of Dogs: Breed Groups Explained
- Beagle Breed Profile: The Complete Owner's Guide
By the most-cited measure, canine psychologist Stanley Coren's obedience rankings, the Afghan Hound sits at the very bottom, meaning it needs the most repetitions to learn a command and obeys least reliably. But this is an obedience score, not an IQ. The Afghan is an ancient, independent sighthound bred to make decisions on its own, so a low ranking reflects stubbornness and self-reliance, not a lack of intelligence.
The Afghan Hound is the breed most consistently labeled the dumbest, because it ranks last on Coren's obedience list of 138 breeds. Right behind it are the Basenji, Bulldog, Chow Chow, and Borzoi. In every case the "dumb" label really means "independent and slow to obey," not genuinely unintelligent, since most of these breeds were built for jobs that reward ignoring the handler.
The English Bulldog is widely considered the laziest dog breed. It is affectionate and mellow and would genuinely rather nap than train or exercise. Part of that low energy is physical: as a flat-faced (brachycephalic) breed, the Bulldog tires quickly and overheats easily, so short, cool activity sessions suit it best. Other notably low-energy breeds include the Basset Hound and the Mastiff.
The Border Collie is ranked the number one smartest dog breed by obedience-and-working intelligence. It can learn a new command in fewer than five repetitions and obey it correctly the first time about 95 percent of the time. Bred to herd sheep in constant partnership with a handler, the Border Collie is wired to watch, learn, and respond, the opposite of the independent breeds on this list.
By Stanley Coren's rankings, the single smartest dog breed is the Border Collie, followed by the Poodle and the German Shepherd. These breeds top the list because they learn commands almost instantly and obey reliably. For the full breakdown of the fast-learning, eager-to-please breeds, see our companion guide to the smartest dog breeds.
The Tibetan Mastiff holds the record for the most expensive dog ever sold: a red Tibetan Mastiff puppy reportedly went for around 1.9 million dollars in China in 2014. These giant, ancient guardian dogs became a status symbol among wealthy buyers. It is worth noting the ordinary Mastiff on this list is unrelated to that record price and is simply a calm, headstrong family guardian.
The Afghan Hound again holds this title under Coren's obedience ranking, but the framing is misleading. Dogs do not have a single measurable IQ. Coren identified three types of intelligence: instinctive (the breed's built-in job), adaptive (independent problem-solving), and working or obedience (trainability). The Afghan scores low only on the last one, while remaining a capable, independent-minded hunter.
Based on Coren's obedience rankings and the current top-ranking lists, the ten breeds most often called the dumbest dog breeds are the Afghan Hound, Basenji, Bulldog, Chow Chow, Borzoi, Bloodhound, Pekingese, Basset Hound, Beagle, and Mastiff. Every one of them is better described as independent, scent-driven, or strong-willed rather than genuinely unintelligent.
Coreen Saito is a pet writer and longtime shelter volunteer with more than a decade in animal rescue. She covers cat behavior, breed care, and the small, ordinary science of sharing a life with companion animals, with a particular focus on honest takes about the products and decisions that actually matter. At home in Arizona, she's outranked by Mac (a dog with the loudest opinion in the house), Rebel (a cat who governs by quiet authority), and Meri (an orange tabby who runs the late shift and the laundry basket). She writes about all three, plus the rescues that keep coming through her life, at LifeWithMinty.com.
Sign up for expert-backed reviews and safety alerts all in one place.
