The Honest Kitchen vs. The Farmer’s Dog Dehydrated Food: How Do They Compare?

Sponsored by The Honest Kitchen. This article contains affiliate links.

The Honest Kitchen vs. The Farmer’s Dog is now a comparison you can make without clearing space in your freezer. The Honest Kitchen Wholemade line and The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh both offer shelf-stable dehydrated food that you prepare with water. For households that want recipe choice and flexible shopping, The Honest Kitchen Wholemade has a particularly strong case: dehydrated food has been central to Honest Kitchen since 2002.

Recipe variety, ingredient standards, preparation, and shopping flexibility are where the two foods actually differ. The Honest Kitchen Wholemade gives you more than 20 dehydrated recipes across four categories, published calories and nutrient figures for each one, a three-minute preparation, and the choice of a one-time box or a subscription. The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh gives you one chicken and grain recipe, portions sized to your dog, and delivery on a subscription schedule. Here is how those differences play out at the bowl and at checkout.

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade vs. The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh at a glance

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade is a collection of more than 20 dehydrated recipes in whole grain, grain free, limited ingredient, and base mix lines, sold in sizes from 15 ounces to 10 pounds as a one-time purchase or a 5% off subscription. The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh, introduced in August 2026, is a single chicken and grain recipe sold through a personalized subscription plan, with portions set by your dog’s age, weight, and activity level. Both are shelf-stable add water foods, so neither one needs freezer space.

Start with The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken option (485 calories per dry cup, suitable for puppies and adults) and the The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh plan (one chicken and grain recipe for adult and senior dogs), then compare them on the four decisions below.

From The Honest KitchenIn stock

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken, 10 lb

Explore The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken, an add water recipe with optional subscription ordering.

$79.99

Buy on The Honest Kitchen

Petful may earn a commission when you click through to The Honest Kitchen, at no extra cost to you.

An Honest Kitchen vs Farmers Dog comparison needs to identify the food being compared. The Farmer’s Dog’s familiar frozen meals and its newer The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh product have different storage and serving requirements. Here, “Farmer’s Dog dehydrated food” refers to The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh, which the company describes as gently cooked food preserved with its Low-Heat Drying Technology. It is the relevant counterpart to The Honest Kitchen Wholemade, rather than a frozen pouch or a DIY nutrient mix.

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade is also distinct from Honest Kitchen’s dry Clusters, wet foods, and base mixes. Its complete recipes, such as Whole Grain Chicken, carry a complete and balanced statement for the life stages they cover. A base mix is designed for you to add your own cooked protein, so it is a different purchase even though it sits in the same dehydrated collection.

For this comparison, Honest Kitchen’s clearest practical advantage is choice: more than 20 recipes, five pack sizes for its Whole Grain Chicken recipe, and the freedom to buy once or subscribe. The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh’s distinguishing feature is that the plan does the portion math for you. Neither a long history nor a subscription tells you which food your dog will eat happily, so a manageable first box is the sensible test.

From The Honest KitchenIn stock

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken, 10 lb

Try a simple measure, mix, and serve routine with The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken.

$79.99

Buy on The Honest Kitchen

Petful may earn a commission when you click through to The Honest Kitchen, at no extra cost to you.

Why Honest Kitchen’s experience matters

The Honest Kitchen’s story starts in 2002, when founder Lucy Postins began developing food for her own dog in her San Diego kitchen. Dehydrating whole food ingredients was part of the original idea: make mealtime more manageable without requiring owners to cook every portion from scratch.

That background matters here because dehydrated meals are an established part of the brand’s identity. The Honest Kitchen Wholemade is the current name for that familiar format. Honest Kitchen’s announcement of The Honest Kitchen Wholemade line describes its refreshed packaging and the addition of dedicated puppy and senior recipes, alongside the existing range.

For a shopper, that experience shows up in things you can read before you buy. Every The Honest Kitchen Wholemade product page lists calories per dry cup, the full ingredient list, protein and fat percentages, preparation steps, and the sizes and prices available. The Honest Kitchen’s food meets human grade standards: its ingredients are fit for human consumption, and its finished food is produced in human food facilities to human food safety standards. This qualification covers both the ingredients and how the food is made.

The Farmer’s Dog introduced The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh in August 2026 as its first shelf-stable option, made by cooking its recipe and drying it with what the company calls Low-Heat Drying Technology. It is human grade and formulated by board-certified veterinary nutritionists, and it gives people who already like the company’s plan-based approach a pantry-friendly way to feed. It is a newer and narrower product than The Honest Kitchen Wholemade: one recipe, adult and senior dogs, and recipe details supplied inside your plan rather than on a public product page.

What 20 years of dehydrated food gets you

More than two decades of making one format means the practical questions have already been worked out: how much water to add, how long to wait, how to store the box, how to use a recipe as a topper, and how to move a dog onto it. Honest Kitchen publishes a 12-month shelf life for the dry food, says prepared food keeps in the refrigerator for up to three days, and cooks its proteins to at least 165°F before dehydration, so the food is not raw.

Honest Kitchen’s routine has stayed the same for two decades: choose a recipe, measure the dry food, add warm water, wait three minutes, and serve. Its dehydrated food guide on Petful covers that format in more depth. The rest of this comparison puts that routine next to the The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh plan on recipes, preparation, storage, and cost.

Recipes, life stages, and ingredient transparency

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade offers more than a single route into dehydrated feeding. The current collection runs to more than 20 products across whole grain, grain free, limited ingredient, and base mix categories, with chicken, turkey, beef, and fish proteins and recipes positioned for puppies, adults, and seniors. Each product page states the life stages it covers, so a puppy recipe and a senior recipe are different formulas, not the same box with a different label.

If you are considering Honest Kitchen grain free dog food, you are choosing between recipes that differ in protein and carbohydrate sources, not just in whether grain is present, and Honest Kitchen has completed AAFCO feeding trials substantiating nutritional adequacy, overall health, and heart health in dogs. Likewise, choosing The Honest Kitchen for puppies means picking a recipe whose label covers growth, such as Whole Grain Chicken, which is suitable for puppies and adults.

Two The Honest Kitchen Wholemade recipes worth distinguishing

• The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken: Chicken, barley, potatoes, flaxseed, oats, peas, and carrots lead the ingredient list. It provides 485 calories per dry cup with 24.5% protein and 14% fat, is suitable for puppies and adults, and comes in 15-ounce, 2-pound, 4-pound, 7-pound, and 10-pound boxes priced from $14.99 to $79.99.
• The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken, Oat & Salmon Senior: Chicken, barley, oats, potatoes, flaxseed, peas, carrots, and salmon, with chondroitin sulfate and turmeric added for joint support. It is lighter at 427 calories per dry cup with 22% protein and 11.5% fat, is made for adult and senior dogs, and comes in 2-pound ($32.99) and 7-pound ($79.99) boxes.

The Senior recipe page gives an older dog a lower-calorie bowl in the same three-minute routine, so a household can move from the Chicken recipe to the Senior recipe without learning a new preparation. Because the two differ by about 60 calories per dry cup, use the Senior feeding guide rather than carrying over the Chicken portion.

The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh is one recipe: chicken and grain, built around chicken breast, oats, potatoes, chicken fat, chicken broth, carrots, sweet potatoes, and pumpkin, and formulated for adult maintenance. Calories, the full ingredient panel, and the nutritional adequacy statement arrive with your plan rather than on the public product page; one published plan quote from August 2026 listed 390 calories per dry cup in a 6-pound bag. We do not carry over The Farmer’s Dog frozen recipes or their nutrition figures into this comparison.

Compare information in the same units

Ingredient transparency helps most when it leads to a fair comparison. The Honest Kitchen Wholemade publishes its ingredient list, calories per dry cup, and protein and fat figures on each product page; The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh supplies the same information inside the plan. Line the two up on the same basis: ingredient list first, then the nutritional adequacy statement, then calories.

From The Honest KitchenIn stock

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken, Oat & Salmon Dehydrated Senior Dog Food, 7 lb

Explore the Chicken, Oat & Salmon Senior recipe and check its own label and serving guide.

$79.99

Buy on The Honest Kitchen

Petful may earn a commission when you click through to The Honest Kitchen, at no extra cost to you.

Dry-food and prepared-food figures need particular care. Adding water changes the weight and volume of a serving without adding calories, so a 10-pound box of The Honest Kitchen Wholemade becomes about 40 pounds of prepared food with the same 19,400 calories. Both foods state calories per dry cup (485 for Whole Grain Chicken, 390 for Instant Fresh in the published quote), and that is the number to compare.

• Record whether a number refers to a dry cup, prepared cup, gram, or kilogram.
• Match the recipe and package size to the food you would actually buy.
• Set the daily portion from the recipe’s own feeding guide, since the two foods differ by about 95 calories per dry cup.
• Keep added toppers and treats separate from the base-food calculation.

Preparation, portions, and storage

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade’s preparation is simple: measure the dry portion, mix with warm water, stir, and wait about three minutes. The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh also requires water and is ready in under a minute. Neither brand fixes a water ratio, because the amount of water sets the consistency rather than the nutrition: more water makes a soupier bowl, less makes a thicker one, and the calories stay the same.

Both formats remove the need to thaw a frozen meal before serving. That can be useful in a small kitchen, while traveling, or when a pet sitter is handling meals. You still need a clean bowl and an accurate measure, and anything you prepare but do not serve goes in the refrigerator: Honest Kitchen says prepared Wholemade keeps for up to three days.

Build the routine around the dry portion

For The Honest Kitchen Wholemade, measure before adding water. If two people feed the same dog, write down the dry amount per meal so neither person has to estimate from the appearance of the finished bowl. A scoop filled slightly differently at each meal can also make a cost estimate harder to follow.

The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh’s personalized portions appeal to someone who wants the plan to do that initial calculation; the questionnaire sets the daily amount from your dog’s age, breed, weight, and activity level. Even then, the bag remains the guide. Changing the amount of water is not the same as changing the amount of food, and a more generous-looking bowl does not mean more calories.

For travel, keep the original label or a clear photograph of it with the food. The recipe name, dry feeding amount, preparation instructions, lot information, and best-by date are more useful than an unlabeled container and a verbal explanation. Pack only what you can keep dry and protected before preparation.

Shelf-stable describes the food before you add water

The pantry convenience applies to the dry food. Honest Kitchen gives The Honest Kitchen Wholemade a 12-month shelf life in its resealable, BPA-free bag and advises against refrigerating the dry food, because moisture is what the bag protects against. Once mixed, treat it as fresh food: refrigerate it and use it within three days, or discard it. The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh is likewise shelf-stable in the pantry until water is added.

Honest Kitchen’s feeding and storage FAQs draw the line between its add water products and its scoop-and-serve formats. For the simplest routine, prepare the amount you intend to serve and reseal the rest. If you prefer batch preparation, three days in the refrigerator is the limit, and Honest Kitchen’s Senior recipe page notes that individual prepared portions can be frozen for up to 30 days.

From The Honest KitchenIn stock

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken, 10 lb

Check the current 10-pound Whole Grain Chicken price and use its label to work out your feeding cost.

$79.99

Buy on The Honest Kitchen

Petful may earn a commission when you click through to The Honest Kitchen, at no extra cost to you.

Cost and buying flexibility

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade’s buying flexibility is a meaningful part of its value. Honest Kitchen offers a one-time purchase as well as subscription ordering at 5% off on a 2- to 12-week cycle you choose, so you can buy a single box to trial a recipe and subscribe only once it works. A Farmer’s Dog subscription builds recurring delivery into the The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh plan, with free shipping, 50% off the first box, and the option to pause or adjust timing; its site offers no one-time purchase option.

People searching for cheaper alternatives to Farmers Dog often land on comparisons with its refrigerated Fresh meal plans, which The Honest Kitchen cites at $2.80 a day for an 11-pound dog and $10.39 a day for a 75-pound Labrador, using The Farmer’s Dog’s own plan examples. Those figures describe the Fresh plans, not The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh. For this decision, compare the regular reorder price of the two add water products, after any first-box discount ends.

A worked The Honest Kitchen Wholemade cost example

At the time of this check, the 10-pound The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken option showed a regular price of $79.99. Its product information lists 485 calories per dry cup and approximately 40 dry cups in a 10-pound box. Those figures let us calculate an approximate cost per 1,000 calories without assuming the daily needs of a particular dog.

That works out to about $2.06 for an illustrative 500-calorie portion or $4.12 for 1,000 calories. These are arithmetic examples, not feeding recommendations. A dog’s daily requirement, the recipe selected, the amount actually measured, shipping, taxes, and current discounts all affect the real bill.

For The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh, The Farmer’s Dog prices each plan individually, so there is no list price to put beside $79.99. One published plan quote from August 2026 came to $144.99 for a 6-pound bag at 390 calories per dry cup, which works out to about $12.85 per 1,000 calories after the standing subscription discount. Your own quote will differ with your dog’s size, but on the figures available, The Honest Kitchen Wholemade’s regular price per calorie runs well below that quote.

Use the same worksheet for both foods

1. Record the regular food cost. Use the amount you expect to pay after the initial promotion, keeping shipping and tax visible.
2. Find the total calories purchased. Multiply the package quantity by its matching calorie unit. Do not combine pounds with a per-cup number without the manufacturer’s conversion.
3. Calculate cost per 1,000 calories. Divide price by total calories, then multiply by 1,000.
4. Apply your dog’s daily portion. Use the feeding guide for the exact recipe; a 50-pound dog needs a different cup count on a 485-calorie food than on a 390-calorie food.
5. Check the order commitment. Compare how much food and how much spending the next shipment represents, not just the smallest daily figure on the page.

For example, an attractive first-order discount may make the trial easier, while a smaller one-time box may make it easier to try a texture without a large initial purchase. These solve different problems. Decide which matters more before choosing the offer that looks cheapest at first glance.

The other common distraction is rehydrated weight. Honest Kitchen describes a 10-pound box as making about 40 pounds of prepared food after water is added. That is a helpful description of the format’s storage convenience. It is not 40 pounds of dry food, and the added water should not be treated as extra food calories in a price comparison.

Which food fits your household?

The Honest Kitchen Wholemade is a strong place to start if you want an established dehydrated line, several recipe directions to explore, and freedom over where and when you reorder. Its format suits the person who is happy to measure food and add water but wants to avoid cooking meals from scratch or organizing freezer deliveries.

The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh may fit an owner who places greater value on personalized portions and a subscription-managed supply. Those are concrete conveniences. They do not require dismissing The Honest Kitchen Wholemade’s recipe range, just as The Honest Kitchen Wholemade’s longer history does not require dismissing the usefulness of a personalized plan.

Choose based on the next month of meals

Think beyond the first bowl. If someone else feeds your dog twice a week, can they follow the instructions easily? If you travel frequently, can you adjust the delivery date? If your household wants to consider another protein or life stage recipe, can you compare the options before placing the next order?

Those questions favor The Honest Kitchen Wholemade for readers who want more control over recipe selection and shopping. Begin with a complete recipe that fits your dog’s life stage, start with a 2-pound or 4-pound box, and move to the 10-pound box or a subscription once the routine is working.

• Recipe-led shopper: Start with The Honest Kitchen Wholemade’s 20-plus recipes and choose by protein, grain, and life stage.
• Plan-led shopper: The Farmer’s Dog Instant Fresh gives you one chicken recipe with the portion already calculated and a delivery schedule you can pause.
• Budget-led shopper: Compare regular prices per 1,000 calories; The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken is about $4.12 at the 10-pound size.
• Small-space household: Either add water format avoids freezer storage; refrigerate prepared food and use it within three days.

Our view is that Honest Kitchen’s combination of category experience, accessible recipe information, and purchasing flexibility makes The Honest Kitchen Wholemade especially compelling for owners who want to choose their own path into dehydrated feeding. The next step is concrete: compare The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Whole Grain Chicken option or the Chicken, Oat & Salmon Senior recipe with the requirements of your own dog and household.

Frequently asked questions

About this comparison: This article uses current manufacturer information. We did not obtain products or conduct a hands-on feeding trial. The Honest Kitchen sponsors this article, and we may earn a commission from its affiliate links.