- Home
- Pet Supplies
- Best Dog Christmas Toys by Play Style
Best Dog Christmas Toys by Play Style
Choose a Christmas toy around the way your dog already plays. Compare six festive options for fetching, carrying, tugging, burrowing, and chewing, with practical checks for construction and size.

Choose a holiday toy for an activity your dog already enjoys.
Petful is reader supported. As an affiliate of platforms like Amazon and Chewy, we may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. There is no extra cost to you.
The best dog Christmas toys give a familiar game a festive twist. A penguin can suit a dog who carries soft toys, while a gingerbread house offers characters to pull out and retrieve. The holiday shape catches your eye; the activity should guide your choice.
These six picks cover different kinds of play. Our comparison uses documented construction and features, rather than hands-on testing or promises about how long a toy will last.

Sign up for expert-backed reviews and safety alerts all in one place.
Dog Christmas toys compared by play style
For a Christmas gift your dog can use, start with a familiar play style and choose a seasonal toy that supports it. Does your dog bring you something to throw, carry a soft toy around, or pull smaller toys from a hiding place? Those observations narrow the choice more effectively than a cute face or festive color.
The important distinction in this assortment is what happens during play. The Elf combines a ball format with a treat pocket. The gingerbread burrow house holds removable characters. The peppermint ring is a nylon chew, while the tree combines plush and rope.
- 1Choose plush for a dog who already enjoys carrying and playing with soft toys.
- 2Compare rope construction: the tree has plush sections threaded with rope, while the reindeer uses knots and braids.
- 3Separate fetching a toy, extracting hidden characters, and chewing before choosing a gift.
| Christmas toy | Play to consider | Documented construction | Buying check |
|---|---|---|---|
| CELEBRATIONS Christmas Tree Dog Rope Toy | Shared tug and fetch | Three plush sections threaded with knotted rope | Choose for the mixed construction, not a durability promise |
| CELEBRATIONS Christmas Elf Tennis Ball Dog Toy | Fetch and treat-pocket exploration | Squeaker and plush crinkle surround with a treat pocket | Check the whole toy's dimensions, including its surround |
| Frisco Christmas Penguin Plush Squeaky Dog Toy, Small | Soft-toy carrying and tossing | Plush exterior and internal squeaker | Verify the selected Small variant's sizing guidance |
| Frisco Christmas Reindeer Rope Dog Toy, Small/Medium | Rope-toy retrieving | Knotted-ball head and body; braided neck and legs | Compare its shape and size with toys your dog already retrieves |
| Benebone Christmas Ring Peppermint Tough Dog Chew Toy, Small | Chewing | Nylon ring with real peppermint and a spreading pocket | Check chewing and sizing guidance; the ring is not edible |
| LIFE IS GOOD Christmas Gingerbread House Burrow Dog Toy | Extracting hidden toys | Plush house with removable, squeaky characters | Check the characters' size as well as the house |

Six festive toys and what each offers
Plush-and-rope combination

CELEBRATIONS Christmas Tree Dog Rope Toy
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
The CELEBRATIONS Christmas Tree Dog Rope Toy has three plush sections with rope running through them and knots adding texture. Embroidered ornaments and a star create the Christmas-tree design.
Consider it when your dog enjoys both soft toys and shared rope play. Its documented uses include tug and fetch, so it offers a seasonal option for those familiar games. The plush sections remain part of the construction; this is not an all-rope toy.
Fetch toy with a treat pocket

CELEBRATIONS Christmas Elf Tennis Ball Dog Toy
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
The CELEBRATIONS Christmas Elf Tennis Ball Dog Toy combines a squeaker with a plush crinkle surround and an embroidered elf face. That surround also doubles as a treat pocket.
Its distinction is the combination of a fetch format and somewhere to investigate a treat. Choose it if those are activities your dog already enjoys. Check its dimensions before buying, rather than assuming the whole toy matches the size and handling of a plain tennis ball. If you plan to use the pocket, our guide to dog Christmas treats covers seasonal options to check against your dog's usual diet.
Small plush squeaker

Frisco Christmas Penguin Plush Squeaky Dog Toy, Small
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
The Frisco Christmas Penguin Plush Squeaky Dog Toy pairs a soft exterior with an internal squeaker. A plaid green scarf and stocking cap supply the holiday details.
This is the straightforward plush choice for a dog who likes carrying a soft toy or playing a tossing game with you. The selected version is Small. That label identifies the variant, but does not establish that it fits every small dog or suits every chewing style.
Braided-rope reindeer

Frisco Christmas Reindeer Rope Dog Toy, Small/Medium
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
The Frisco Christmas Reindeer Rope Dog Toy uses knotted balls for its head and body, with braided rope forming the neck and legs. Its documented play uses include tossing, fetching, and retrieving.
Choose this Small/Medium version for a rope-focused shape rather than the tree's plush-and-rope combination. The construction is the useful comparison: the reindeer's holiday outline comes from knots and braids. It should not be treated as proof that the toy can withstand prolonged destructive chewing.
Nylon chew format

Benebone Christmas Ring Peppermint Tough Dog Chew Toy, Small
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
The Benebone Christmas Ring Peppermint Tough Dog Chew Toy is made from nylon with real peppermint. Its circular shape offers a way to grip the toy, and a built-in pocket accommodates a spreadable treat.
This Small version fills the chewing role in the assortment, rather than the plush, fetch, or burrowing roles. The peppermint describes an ingredient in the toy; it does not make the ring edible. Check the maker's sizing and chewing guidance before choosing it.
Plush burrow set

LIFE IS GOOD Christmas Gingerbread House Burrow Dog Toy
Petful may earn a commission when you click through to Chewy, at no extra cost to you.
The LIFE IS GOOD Christmas Gingerbread House Burrow Dog Toy holds soft, squeaky characters inside a plush house. Its embroidered gingerbread details make the container part of the festive design.
The main activity is pulling out the characters, then returning them to the house for another round. That makes it a different gift from a single plush animal. Consider it for a dog who already enjoys extracting smaller toys, while checking the individual characters' suitability before play.
Choose plush, squeaky, and crinkly toys
Start with how your dog uses soft toys. Carrying one around, bringing it back after a toss, and opening seams are different behaviors. A plush Christmas toy is a closer match for the first two than a reason to overlook the third.
For a simple soft-toy gift, the Frisco penguin combines plush fabric and a squeaker. The Elf adds a crinkle surround, while the burrow set provides squeaky characters to remove from a house. Pick the feature your dog seeks out, rather than assuming more sounds make a better present.
Before choosing, check:
- Whether your dog usually carries soft toys or pulls them apart.
- Whether a squeaker or crinkly texture holds their interest.
- Whether you want one toy to toss or a set to put back together.
Supervise play and remove a toy when damage exposes or loosens parts. A festive design does not change that decision.
Match rope and fetch toys to the dog
The functional difference between the plush-segment rope tree and the braided-rope reindeer is their construction. The tree threads rope through plush sections; the Frisco reindeer builds its head, body, neck, and legs from knots and braids. Choose according to the shapes and textures your dog already likes retrieving.
For small or large dogs, check the exact model's dimensions and manufacturer guidance. Use model-specific size guidance: Small and Small/Medium labels are not universally suitable or interchangeable measurements. The Elf's ball format also does not tell you the size of its plush surround.
Use three checks before a fetch game:
- Confirm that the complete toy suits your dog, including attached sections.
- Choose a clear space suited to the game.
- Inspect the toy before and after play, including rope strands and seams.
If your dog tends to settle down and dismantle a retrieved toy, recognize that change in activity. Fetch suitability alone does not establish chewing suitability.
Separate hide-and-seek play from chewing
Fun Christmas enrichment ideas for dogs can be as simple as repeating a game they already understand. The gingerbread burrow house offers characters to extract; the Elf offers a treat pocket to investigate. The Elf treat pocket and burrow house offer different retrieval activities: fetching the Elf ball and extracting characters from the house. Pocket capacity, piece count and dimensions are not supplied, and neither feature guarantees lasting interest.
A plush burrow set is also different from a snuffle mat: here, the documented activity is retrieving hidden characters, not searching through fabric folds for food. This Christmas-specific assortment covers festive gifts. An owner comparing general interactive-toy selection can use our existing guide to the best interactive dog toys helps match an activity to your dog's preferences.
Without testing or primary guidance, we cannot substantiate indestructible, aggressive-chewer or dental-safety assurances. Chewing is a separate choice. The Benebone ring's nylon construction distinguishes it from the plush options, but “tough” in a name is not evidence of an indestructible Christmas dog toy. If you are shopping primarily for an aggressive chewer, use our best dog toys for aggressive chewers guide to consider material, size, and chewing behavior before choosing a holiday design.
Build a gift around the way your dog already plays
The toys dogs love most vary with their existing play preference; there is no universal favorite toy. Your dog's existing play preference is the more useful starting point. Watch what they choose when several familiar toys are available:
- Carrying: They pick up a soft toy and keep it nearby.
- Chasing: They bring something back for another throw.
- Tugging: They invite you into a shared pulling game.
- Extracting: They work smaller toys out of a container.
Match that play style first, then choose the festive version. Check rope construction, individual burrow characters, and the complete shape of a fetch toy before deciding.

To make Christmas special, include shared play with the present. A familiar activity, such as supervised fetch or helping your dog discover burrow characters, gives you something to do together. You do not need a complicated new game or a whole basket of toys. For smaller extras to go with a toy, our guide to dog stocking stuffers compares treats, small toys, and walking accessories.
If you are choosing gifts for dog owners, useful accessories may be a better fit than another toy. Our best pet gifts guide covers that broader decision. For someone else's dog, ask which activities and toy sizes already work before choosing the Christmas version.
Size labels to check for small and large dogs
Size is where a festive toy is easiest to misjudge. A listing name tells you which variant you are buying, but it does not describe your dog's mouth, strength, or play habits. Treat each label as the start of the check rather than the answer.
Here is what the product information says about size for each pick:
- Frisco Christmas Penguin Plush Squeaky Dog Toy: the selected version is Small.
- Frisco Christmas Reindeer Rope Dog Toy: the selected version is Small/Medium.
- Benebone Christmas Ring Peppermint Tough Dog Chew Toy: the selected version is Small.
- CELEBRATIONS tree, CELEBRATIONS Elf, and LIFE IS GOOD gingerbread house: no size variant is named, so check each listing's dimensions.
For a small dog, the Small and Small/Medium labels are a reasonable place to begin, but compare the complete toy with your dog. The Elf's plush surround adds to the ball format, and the gingerbread house comes with separate characters to check one by one.
For a large dog, none of the selected versions is labeled Large. That does not rule out every pick, but it does mean confirming the exact dimensions and the maker's size guidance before buying. If you cannot confirm a suitable size, a different gift is a better choice than a holiday design that fits the theme but not the dog.
Christmas toys for dogs who chew hard
If your dog tends to dismantle soft toys, start by separating chewing from the other games in this list. Five of the six picks are built for carrying, tossing, tugging, retrieving, or extracting characters. Only one is a chew format.
Here is how the picks divide:
- Chew format: the Benebone Christmas Ring Peppermint Tough Dog Chew Toy, made from nylon with real peppermint and a circular shape to grip.
- Rope: the CELEBRATIONS tree threads rope through plush sections, while the Frisco reindeer is built from knots and braids.
- Plush: the Frisco penguin, the Elf's crinkle surround, and the gingerbread house with its squeaky characters.
A name that includes "tough" is a product name, not a durability rating, and no pick here has evidence that it is indestructible. For a dog who chews hard, the nylon ring is the closest match in format, provided Benebone's sizing and chewing guidance fit your dog.
The plush and rope picks can still be good gifts for that dog when you use them in shared sessions. Play together, then put the toy away instead of leaving it for solo chewing, and retire it when seams, rope strands, or characters start to come apart.
Questions readers ask
The LIFE IS GOOD gingerbread burrow house is the clearest match here because it holds removable, squeaky characters. Choose it for extracting hidden toys. The Elf's treat pocket offers a different activity: investigating a place that can hold a treat.
No evidence establishes any of these toys as indestructible. Regular inspection and responding to damage still matter, whether the toy contains plush, rope, or nylon. Choose by construction and your dog's behavior, rather than treating a durability label as a guarantee.
The CELEBRATIONS tree has three plush sections threaded with knotted rope. The Frisco reindeer uses knotted balls for its head and body and braided rope for its neck and legs. The tree offers mixed construction; the reindeer is rope-focused.
No. The Benebone ring is a nylon chew toy made with real peppermint. Its spreading pocket can accommodate a treat, but the ring itself is not food. Follow the manufacturer's guidance for choosing, using, and replacing the toy.
Three of the six picks include a squeaker. The Frisco Christmas Penguin has an internal squeaker, the CELEBRATIONS Elf combines a squeaker with a crinkle surround, and the LIFE IS GOOD gingerbread house holds soft, squeaky characters. The CELEBRATIONS tree, the Frisco reindeer, and the Benebone ring do not list a squeaker in their descriptions. Choose a squeaky toy only if that sound already holds your dog's interest.
Yes. The Christmas design is seasonal, but the play format is not. A rope toy still serves tug and fetch, a plush squeaker still suits a dog who carries soft toys, and a nylon chew ring still meets a chewing habit in January. Choose the festive toy for the game your dog already plays, and keep inspecting it before each session instead of retiring it with the decorations.
Plush Christmas toys suit dogs who carry, cuddle, or toss soft toys, and fit less well with dogs who open seams. In this list, the Frisco penguin is fully plush, the CELEBRATIONS Elf has a plush crinkle surround, the tree has three plush sections threaded with rope, and the gingerbread house holds plush characters. Supervise play and remove a plush toy once damage loosens or exposes parts.

Coreen Saito is a pet writer and longtime shelter volunteer with more than a decade in animal rescue. She covers cat behavior, breed care, and the small, ordinary science of sharing a life with companion animals, with a particular focus on honest takes about the products and decisions that actually matter. At home in Arizona, she's outranked by Mac (a dog with the loudest opinion in the house), Rebel (a cat who governs by quiet authority), and Meri (an orange tabby who runs the late shift and the laundry basket). She writes about all three, plus the rescues that keep coming through her life, at LifeWithMinty.com.

Sign up for expert-backed reviews and safety alerts all in one place.


